Jamie R Thomann Accident, Circle O Trailer Park Shelbyville, Tn, Articles A

Forced to abandon his family, he and his companions are taken to the nearby city to be sacrificed. The movie continues with a harrowing march of tears and blood. Suddenly I am afraid." Snake Ink: Lift yourself up, Drunkards Four. Gibson has said of Hansen's involvement: "Richard's enthusiasm for what he does is infectious. In the ending of both "Heart of Darkness" and "Apocalypse Now," the protagonists confront their version of Kurtz. Shirdi sai baba bhajans by lata mangeshkar, Twilight princess hd texture pack dolphin gamecube, Adobe photoshop cc 2017 has stopped working, When was maui revealed 6th edition published. . And although the conquest of the ancient civilizations of Mesoamerica by the conquistadors remains behind the scenes, a hint of historical events is obvious: several thousand Spaniards conquered millions of Indians also because the latter were mortally afraid of pale-faced aliens and their unseen animals horses. Natasha was already was jealous of the great relationship that Dahlia and Ceci shared, but now she's being deserted once more she's seriously pissed. Does blunted die in Apocalypto?lunted dies like a hero, and Jaguar Paw escapes, though wounded. When Middle Eye realizes that Flint Sky is Jaguar Paw's father, he kills Flint Sky and mockingly renames Jaguar Paw "Almost". The movie misses this important distinction by creating a spurious contrast between a rural idyll and an urban miasma of excess and violence. They are then decapitated and their headless bodies flung down the massive frontal staircase to the cheers of the ruck below. Forced to abandon his family, he and his companions are taken to the nearby city to be sacrificed. The omen was foretold, and now we have a fear more grave. In march 2023, Tim Norman sentenced to life in prison in Sweetie Pie's murder-for-hire plot. Even the craziest of conspiracy theories do not suggest that Spain set about conquering the Americas before it had invented itself. A number of animals are featured in Apocalypto, including a Baird's tapir and a black jaguar. #Apocalypto ending explained skin When I catch him, I will peel his skin and have him watch me wear it. The Man said, "I want to have good sight." This does demand a more detailed look into Mr. Gibson's motives for writing, directing, and producing this film. Would you like to know how you will die? The time period conveyed during the film had ended about 100 or so years before the Spanish arrived and most of the methods of torture and sacrifice was from a completely unrelated culture and wouldn't have involved the main character at all based on his place in society. And yet, all of a sudden, a boatload of Spaniards turn up waving great big Christian crosses. Jaguar Paw suffers an arrow wound, but escapes into the jungle, killing Zero Wolf's son Cut Rock in the process. Unfortunately, we dont see any of that reflected in the film. The victims are splayed on a column at the top of a pyramid, and a priest cracks their ribcage open with an obsidian knife to pluck out their still-beating hearts. GE 4 is gonna involve time travel. [23] Gibson has defined the title, based on Greek word (Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: [[wikt:|]], apokalupt), as "a new beginning or an unveiling a revelationEverything has a beginning and an end, and all civilizations have operated like that". We must not let this man make feet from us. I was impressed with Rudy Youngblood's performance as Jaguar Paw. Mel Gibson's latest film, Apocalypto, tells a story set in pre-Columbian Central America, with the Mayan Empire in decline. "[25] On Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 68 out of 100, based on 37 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews". What is the ending of Apocalypto? That view is quite difficult to. The ending doesn't break any rules because there aren't any for this case at all. Though unnamed in the movie, the Europeans at the end of the film are led by Christopher Columbus, who made first contact with Mayan cultures in 1502. However, it must be admitted that, deviating from historical plausibility in the details, Gibson managed to create an impressive image of the pagan civilization of the pre-Columbian era. Certain religions, however, hold their apocalyptic beliefs to be fairly central in their overall theology. As the Mayan kingdom faces its decline, a young man is taken on a perilous journey to a world ruled by fear and oppression. As a joke, Gibson inserted a subliminal cameo of the bearded director in a plaid shirt with a cigarette hanging from his mouth posing next to a group of dust-covered Maya. According to Allan Wall of Banderas News, "The art, architecture and setting of the movie mixes aspects of different epochs and regions within the Mayan civilization. It is now widely accepted that kuru was transmitted among members of the Fore tribe of Papua New Guinea via funerary cannibalism. As director of the Mirador Basin Project, he works to preserve a large swath of the Guatemalan rain forest and its Maya ruins. The Maya dominated Mexico's Yucatn peninsula until the 16th century. By 200 B.C, their landscape was dominated by cities of thousands of people composed of monumental temples, royal palaces and public art. [7] [8] Hansen published an essay on the film and a critical commentary on the criticisms of the film. [38] In contrast, Mayanist, David Stuart, stated that human sacrifice was not rare and based on carvings and mural paintings, there are "more and greater similarities between the Aztecs and Mayas. Jaguar Paw: I do not understand. Jaguar Paw: Where are they taking us? There was tremendous Aztec influence by this time. Jaguar Paw - Apocalypto (2006) Having escaped a horrible death at the hands of the Mayans and defeated the . I can only hope that audiences seeing this movie will be motivated to learn about the Maya present and past rather than be sated by Gibsons sacrificial offering at the altar of entertainment. He was able to reassure us and make us feel secure that what we were writing had some authenticity as well as imagination. I could make guesses, but I do not really know what Mel Gibson was trying to say. In fact, Gibsons villagers would have conducted such sacrifices for their household and agricultural rites, although we never see them do so in the movie. [5] In the audio commentary of the film's first DVD release, Safinia states that the old shaman's story (played by Espiridion Acosta Cache, a modern-day Maya storyteller[6]) was modified from an authentic Mesoamerican tale that was re-translated by Hilario Chi Canul, a professor of Maya, into the Yucatec Maya language for the film. book series in the theatrical version of the film. Just hearing the close equivalent of the Mayan language feels far more natural than if the actors were speaking English. As the party approaches the raiders' Mayan city, they encounter razed forests and vast fields of failed maize crops, alongside villages decimated by an unknown disease. 2023 BDG Media, Inc. All rights reserved. I did not raise you to see you live with fear. warren community center swim lessons. However, its very hard to shake the shadow of Mel Gibsons malicious, racially-charged tirades. They reveal gods undertaking rites that bring the world into creation. Huts are set on fire, many villagers are killed, and the surviving adults are taken prisoner. While the Mayans certainly did engage in human sacrifice, theres no evidence that they did it on as large a scale all at once as depicted in the film that was a practice associated with the Aztecs. #7. "[40], Richard D. Hansen, a historical consultant on the film, stated in an interview with The Washington Post that the film does "give the feeling [that the Maya were] a sadistic lot", and expressed being "a little apprehensive about how the contemporary Maya will take it. David van Biema, in an article written for Time magazine, questions whether the Spaniards are portrayed as saviors of the Mayas since they are depicted ominously with Jaguar Paw acknowledging their arrival as a threat and deciding to return to the woods.[49]. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Apocalypto". Flint Sky: Those people in the forest, what did you see on them?Jaguar Paw: I do not understand.Flint Sky: Fear. Curl Nose: We tell stories of a place stone-built. You can unsubscribe at any time. And a Man sat alone, drenched deep in sadness. Slathered in blue body paint, they are led through the central ceremonial precinct of the city. The movies infamous violence begins when the tribes idyllic world is shattered by a surprise attack of fierce raiders seeking both captives and slaves to take back to their city. That this is supposed to be a statement about how entirely too many movies nowadays have main characters who are written with all the subtlety of the most blatant of self insert, Mary Sue characters. Once the raiders and captives reach the city, the females are sold into slavery while the males are escorted to the top of a step pyramid to be sacrificed before the Mayan king and queen. The sacred time is near. Christopher Columbus sneaks in at the end. Spanish accounts note that some Maya pyramids along the Yucatan coast were covered with blood presumably human, though the Spanish never witnessed any of the sacrifices themselves. The Europeans put pressure on the Mayans to put an end to the ritual. Apocalypto is a 2006 film, set in the declining period of the Maya civilization, depicting the journey of a Mesoamerican tribesman who must escape human sacrifice and rescue his family after the capture and destruction of his village. How does apocalypto end? "[34] Actor Edward James Olmos said, "I was totally caught off guard. They then pass a little girl infected with the plague who prophesies the end of the Mayan world. APOCALYPTO, Mel Gibson's latest movie, has excellent production values, direction and acting, and is set in a unique world that is unlike anything you've probably ever seen. Apocalypto (/ p k l p t o /) is a 2006 historical epic film produced, co-written, and directed by Mel Gibson.The film features a cast of Native American and Indigenous Mexican actors consisting of Rudy Youngblood, Raoul Trujillo, Mayra Srbulo, Dalia Hernndez, Gerardo Taracena, Rodolfo Palacios, Bernardo Ruiz Juarez, Ammel Rodrigo Mendoza, Ricardo Diaz Mendoza, and . 1. The prediction of the solar eclipse is the only allusion to one of the more celebrated and important facets of Maya civilization their advanced state of knowledge in mathematics, astronomy and geometry. Maya calendrical, astronomical and mathematical systems were so advanced that they could predict eclipses, track Venus as morning and evening star, and compute the annual solstices and equinoxes decades in advance. However, he was allegedly added back into the film for the Blu-Ray release. Meanwhile, Seven and Turtles Run remain trapped in the pit after a suspicious raider severs the vine leading out of it. The movie tracks a young Mayan man who is captured in a surprise raid on his village. The Spanish Conquistadores arrive, armed with swords, guns, and diseases. '"ialogue Jaguar Paw: The heart. If you could figure out the worst case scenario, then that is what would happen. Actor Robert Duvall called it "maybe the best movie I've seen in 25 years". The non-traditional score features a large array of exotic instruments and vocals by Pakistani singer Rahat Fateh Ali Khan. Many modern Maya rituals, such as processions or prayers, are deliberate and serious affairs. Mel Gibson's About Civilizations. Since beginning in 1979 with the sparse, brutal revenge thriller Mad Max, the series has survived four dramatically different cinematic outings, all of which were directed by George Miller . He has completed one tour of duty in Vietnam, only to go home a changed man, miserable amid the confines of civilization. Apocalypto seems to have been made to argue that Mayan civilisation was evil and revolting, and that it was a jolly good thing the Spanish turned up to conquer it. What Has Mel Gibson Got Against the Church? End of game, your character travels back in time and stops Aragami invasion from ever happening. In an action scene that springs entirely from Gibsons imagination, our hero is able to escape the city. The use of the Yucatec Mayan language (which is the modern approximation of the Mayan language) also adds to the experience. [40] Anthropologist, Traci Ardren, felt that Apocalypto was biased because "no mention is made of the achievements in science and art, the profound spirituality and connection to agricultural cycles, or the engineering feats of Maya cities". Deep rotting fear. At this point, he has taken three arrows already and you are lead to believe he collapsed to his knees from the pain and loss of blood. Apocalypto sets itself up very early on, making it easy to follow the characters and understand their world. while he's being held back. This is akin to telling a story about English pilgrims founding the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and showing them living in longhouses described in Beowulf. In fact, Gibson incorporates Maya images from as far back as 300 B.C. Finally, they show Jaguar Paw and his family wandering through the jungle about to start a new tribe. Dahlia discovers that Natasha is still floating about in there.superintendent Veeck left her to rot in there. . Dahlia (understandably) can't stay in a place like this anymore and plans to move Ceci out. See also Can Arowana Fish Live With Oscar? Once Dahlia discovers where Ceci is, she rushes in the bathroom, only to find the water is filling up the whole bathroom, and she cannot break through the glass to get to her daughter. Considering both the Aztecs and the Maya, they eventually chose the Maya for their high sophistication and their eventual decline. The raider who encounters the little girl is clearly unnerved and later expresses worry that the end is near. Group of European explorers that landed in the America's in the late 1400's. Inaccurately portrayed in the movie as coming 600 years earlier. Admittedly, not much is known about Mayan humour, but there is no reason to assume it would have been exactly like that of spoilt American frat boys. By mentioning that marker of time I mean to say I knew. GE 5: Aragami invasion happened anyway, and we're starting the series over again because we're out of ideas. During the attack, Jaguar Paw lowers his pregnant wife Seven and their young son Turtles Run into a pit. Forgive us for this trespass against your son the jaguar. Their pursuit is now irrelevant, as their world is about to end. The site's critical consensus reads: "Apocalypto is a brilliantly filmed, if mercilessly bloody, examination of a once great civilization. Ceci goes off to live with her dad in a different part of the city.The sacred time is near. Apocalypto Ending Explained and Film Analysis Although "Apocalypto" has all the components of a classic action movie: a dynamic plot, a life-and-death struggle, an unsinkable protagonist and an indispensable happy ending, Gibson's film can rightfully be called a large-scale philosophical story about the fate of people and civilizations. Someone cons the big lunk of the gang into eating its testicles, at which they all fall about laughing. Once in the city, some of Gibsons villagers are designated for sacrifice. Snake Ink: Lift yourself up, Drunkards Four. Later, heavy rain begins to fall, threatening to drown Jaguar Paw's family, who are still trapped in the pit. Before we go any further, we need to address the anti-Semitic, racist, misogynistic elephant in the room. At least that's what I think you're putting down. Would a unified and righteous Mayan culture have been able to survive the far superior military technology of the invading Spaniards? Before Flint Sky is killed and before Jaguar Paw is sent out to run for his life, the Mayan warrior removes the necklaces they wear. In one scene, a little girl, mourning at the side of her dead mother, approaches the Mayan raiding party that has captured Jaguar Paw and his companions. This is especially true in relationships. Create your own unique website with customizable templates. [21] Due to an enthusiastic response from exhibitors, Disney opened the film on more than 2,500 screens in the United States. Most of the step pyramids seen at the Maya city were models designed by Thomas E. Sanders. In fact, the Maya made regular use of the concept of zero centuries before Fibonacci introduced it to Europe. And when the Man had all the gifts that they could give, he left. But in the movie, after two hours of excess, hyperbole and hysteria, the Spaniards represent the arrival of sanity to the Maya world. SUPPORT HISTORY BUFFS ON PATREON https://www.patreon.com/HistoryBuffsSpecial thanks to AlternateHistoryHub for being in this episode. [36] According to polls performed by the newspaper Reforma, 80% of polled Mexicans labeled the film as "very good" or "good". Its true that sacrificial practices among the Maya did change somewhat during the final centuries before the Spanish arrival. Villagers who survived a savage attack are taken by their captors through the jungle to the central Mayan city. Throughout the movie, these anachronisms make Maya civilization seem timeless, and undermine the idea that the Maya could and did respond to change. Create your own unique website with customizable templates. raywest Add a different answer More questions & answers from Apocalypto Join the mailing list He disposes of them one by one as you soon begin to realise that the prophecy the little girl foretold earlier is coming true. The Maya, at the time of the conquest, were intractable and fiercely autonomous. One thing I have discovered in life is that fear usually creates that which the person feared. The best scene in Jurassic Park contains no dinosaurs. The raiders tie the captives together and set out on a long forced march through the jungle, leaving the children behind to fend for themselves. They use this to swat a tapir to death, and divide its flesh up between them. Over several millennia, the Maya underwent many cycles of growth and decline, each with its own major cities. Much of what we see recorded by the Maya is a form of sacrifice known as auto-sacrifice self-inflicted bloodletting involving piercing ear lobes, fingers, tongues and penises. She makes it clear that she wants an eternal companion, being either Dahila or Ceci, so Dahila lets herself be drowned so her daughter can survive. [41] The film has also been criticized by Guatemalan activist, Ignacio Ochoa, as "an offensive and racist notion that Maya people were brutal to one another long before the arrival of Europeans and thus they deserved, in fact, needed, rescue. According to Ardren, Apocalypto "replays, in glorious big-budget technicolor, an offensive and racist notion that Maya people were brutal to one another long before the arrival of Europeans and thus they deserved, in fact, they needed, rescue. It fails, hard. He dares the nine Raiders to challenge him, and they die one by one : killed by a jaguar; a snake; drowning and one killed by Zero Wolf himself. The movie ends with the Spaniards coming. The idea, proposed by the movie, that Maya civilization was at the verge of final self-destruction makes for good drama, but does not reflect the depth of this civilizations resilience and history. Another disputed scene, when Jaguar Paw and the rest of the captives are used as target practice, was acknowledged by the filmmakers to be invented as a plot device for igniting the chase sequence. Most villages resisted the Spaniards. There are a lot of successful movies where a question is kept alive intentionally through out the movie and never a perfect answer is given because public like mystery and they likes solving it themselves if no answer is given (like you are trying :) ). They're shown as these extremely barbaric people, when in fact, the Maya were a very sophisticated culture." He was recast in favor of Rudy Youngblood. Gibson filmed Apocalypto mainly in Catemaco, San Andrs Tuxtla and Paso de Ovejas in the Mexican state of Veracruz. The film was distributed by Buena Vista Pictures in North America and Icon Film Distribution in the United Kingdom and Australia. Set in Yucatn, Mexico, around the year 1502, Apocalypto portrays the hero's journey of a young man named Jaguar Paw, a late Mesoamerican hunter and his fellow tribesmen who are captured by an invading force. The film was a box office success, grossing over $120 million worldwide, and received mostly positive reviews, with critics praising Gibson's direction, Dean Semler's cinematography, and the performances of the cast, though the portrayal of Mayan civilization and historical accuracy were criticized. However, Apocalypto takes many liberties with the history of the Mayan civilization that it could be perceived as detrimental to the descendants of its people. Subscribe for free to Inverses award-winning daily newsletter! And so it went with all the animals. Christopher Columbus sneaks in at the end. The villagers would have understood the threat of raids, battles and wars which were a regular part of Maya society. What is the laughing sickness in Apocalypto? The tacit paternalism is devastating. While the Eden-like scene makes for great cinematography, it is not supported by archaeological data. Mel Gibson wanted Apocalypto to feature sets with buildings rather than relying on computer-generated images. Richard D. Hansen comments, "There was nothing in the post-classic period that would match the size and majesty of that pyramid in the film. I think it was the best artistic film of that year. The Jaguar Paw is both an Indian from a forest tribe who lived in the early 16th century and an archetypal image that everyone understands. Then someone else tricks him into rubbing hot chilli sauce on his own private parts. "[11] An example of attention to detail is the left arm tattoo of Seven, Jaguar Paw's wife, which is a horizontal band with two dots above the Mayan symbol for the number seven. Apocalyptic writings are marked by distinctive literary features, particularly prediction of future events and accounts of visionary experiences or journeys to heaven, often involving . Not surrendering to fear is a great principle. The temples are in the shape of those of Tikal in the central lowlands classic style but decorated with the Puuc style elements of the northwest Yucatn centuries later. Apocalypto ending explained bn zb Summaries. He flees through the jungle, and with only two pursuers remaining, he bursts out of the forest onto a beach. In the Maya civilization, a peaceful tribe is brutally attacked by warriors seeking slaves and human beings for sacrifice for their gods. By subscribing to this BDG newsletter, you agree to our. The film portrays all classes of Maya society, from slaves and builders to warriors, priests and rulers. Within decades of the first contact with the Spaniards, the Maya would die in the hundreds of thousands as European diseases, colonial exploitation and cruelty took root. The cast is also comprised of all Native Americans and Indigenous Mexican actors. Apocalypto Ending Explained and Film Analysis. He ties a rope to a nearby rock so that they can climb out again before running back to the village to help, killing a raider along the way. The villagers are attacked and captured by men from a Maya metropolis. Dahlia then sees Natasha in the tub drowning Ceci, and begs that she stops. Maya cities were likely to have been much healthier than contemporary European ones. After many centuries of misguided and simplistic views of the Maya, recent scholarship has shown the complexity and historical depth of their civilization. Curl Nose: I do not know, but the earth bleeds. Jaguar Paw is a young Mayan man who is kidnapped by a group of holcanes and taken to an old ball court where they are instructed to run the length of the court in pairs toward the forest at the end with the cynical promise of freedom should they make it. What about the Mayans was destroying themselves from within? So fierce was the Maya defense of their lands that Corts avoided much of this coast, choosing to land farther west along what is known today as the coast of Veracruz. The movie was so predictable after the escape from the Mayan city. The logical explanation is that the premature teaser trailer was sliced together from sample shots and footage, before the official casting was finished. All of the indigenous people depicted in the film were Maya. During the attack, Jaguar Paw lowers his pregnant wife Seven and their young son Turtles Run into a cenote. The world-building is done impressively well. Again, the historical facts tell a different and more compelling story. Zero Wolf and Middle Eye take their men to chase after him. Now his sadness will stop." Apocalypto aimed to remind that a civilization unable to preserve its long-held traditions, beliefs, and spirituality will face destruction. Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. Their sophisticated political systems, extraordinary visual culture, advanced science and development of the only written language in the Americas have long endeared them to historians. The disease is smallpox, brought to the new world by Spanish explorers and traders. Directed by Mel Gibson. Jaguar Paw returns just in time to save his family from the flooding pit, and is overjoyed at the sight of his newborn son. Apocalypto will be forever remembered as Mel Gibsons last film before the world saw him for what he truly is, though that revelation has barely put a damper on his ability to make movies in Hollywood. Plot Overview. Maya in the Thunderdome This film is set in completely the wrong century. Apocalypto is a 2006 epic historical adventure film produced, co-written, and directed by Mel Gibson. But the owl replied, "No. It will crawl into the soul of anyone who engages it. But Gibson forces us to empathize with the ingenuous villagers by juxtaposing their baffled terror with the puerile sadism of their attackers. (KMOV/AP) - A former St. Louis reality TV star convicted for his role in a murder-for-hire plot will be spending the rest . He tries to keep walking but collapses. It is also known as the laughing sickness due to the pathologic bursts of laughter which are a symptom of the disease. Although an emphasis on Maya intellectual achievement would have been appropriate, it would have been inconsistent with the movies theme of a cruel and savage Maya civilization. Our job is to do a beautiful movie."[12]. Meanwhile, the two remaining raiders chase Jaguar Paw towards the coast, where all three are astonished at the sight of Spanish conquistadors making their way to the shore. Out of all the scenes in Apocalypto, this one encompasses the film the best. Screenwriter and co-producer Farhad Safinia first met Mel Gibson while working as an assistant during the post-production of The Passion of the Christ. Apocalypto is certainly a well-made film. Finally, some catastrophic environmental changelike an extremely long, intense period of droughtmay have wiped out the Classic Maya civilization. It's a sign of the warrior passing over to death. Flint Sky: Your wife? The production team consisted of a large group of make-up artists and costume designers who worked to recreate the Maya look for the large cast. Atherton also has a cameo as the cross-bearing Franciscan friar who appears on a Spanish ship at the end of the film. Pursued by his captors, he runs through a dead corn field and hides in a field of decapitated corpses. The message isnt subtle: the Mayan civilization caused their own downfall long before the Spanish showed up. So even though Jane the Virgin followed a relatively realistic pregnancy timeline for Jane, where she becomes pregnant in the first episode and gives birth by the season 1 finale, everything else was fake. See also: Maya textiles. His tribe comes under attack by raiders from the Mayan city where many of his fellow villagers are cruelly slaughtered the rest are captured to be sold as slaves or used as human sacrifices. The Aztecs were clearly ruthless in their conquest and pursuit of sacrificial victims, a practice that spilled over into some of the Maya areas."[11]. The film features a cast of Native American and Indigenous Mexican actors consisting of Rudy Youngblood, Raoul Trujillo, Mayra Srbulo, Dalia Hernndez, Gerardo Taracena, Rodolfo Palacios, Bernardo Ruiz Juarez, Ammel Rodrigo Mendoza, Ricardo Diaz Mendoza, and Israel Contreras. As the two raiders are confounded by the Spanish ships, Jaguar Paw uses the distraction to flee and return to his village. Several key film critics alluded to the incident in their reviews of Apocalypto: In his positive review, The New York Times A. O. Scott commented: "say what you will about him about his problem with booze or his problem with Jews he is a serious filmmaker." Other disputed depictions of the Mayas include the sacrifice of commoners and mass graves. Other mistake: When Jaguar Paw is running to reach the corn to escape and gets knocked down by an arrow; Middle Eye was about to whack him when Blunted intervened. However, in most cases, such sacrifices were of single victims of noble rank whose identity was prominently recorded for posterity, not a mass of unknown farmers. Blunted: No, her mother. I did not raise you to see you live with fear. Blunted is held down while Sky Flower is forced into a hut where she is presumably raped and killed. 900, Maya civilization in that region had collapsed. The story focuses on Jaguar Paw, a tribesman from a hunting village deep in the jungle. The franchise is known for its futuristic plot, action-packed scenes, and unforgettable characters. This raises the problem of whats not in the movie. [36], Aspects of Mayan culture and civilization depicted in Apocalypto is considered by scholars to be historically inaccurate.